"Bear in mind the truth of the old saying that the end is not obvious at the beginning."
-- Artabanus to Xerxes, King of Persia, 480 B.C., as quoted by Herodotus
In
search of clues from
the world's first democracy as to what's ailing the American version,
I've been immersing myself in the history of
Ancient Greece. Among the many books I've read on the subject is "The
Histories," by Herodotus, a 5th-Century B.C. Greek historian (actually,
he's considered "the father of history") who chronicled the 20-year war
between the Greeks and Persians that began around 499 B.C.
It's
a fascinating, if often confusing, work, filled with hundreds of
unpronounceable names and long-forgotten cultures. And it has much to
teach us about our disaster in Iraq. For it
seems that the tragic consequences of this irrational misadventure, as
well as those of a potential new disaster, in Iran, could have been
foreseen 2,500 years ago.
It was
early in the 5th Century B.C., and King Xerxes, leader of the most
powerful nation in the world, held a grudge. Ten years earlier, the
city-state
of Athens had actively aided rebellions against Persian rule by
communities on Aegean islands and the west coast of present-day Turkey.
The rebels were thwarted by Darius, Xerxes' father, who then attacked
Greece. But Dad hadn't quite finished the job. Now the time had come to
settle scores. "You
ought to march against Greece," one of Xerxes' advisers urged. "It will
enhance your
reputation, and also make people think twice in the future before
attacking your territory."
I read the words again, then a third time. Why did they sound so familiar? What was this feeling of reverse deja vu?
But
of course. Early in the 21st Century, President Bush, leader of the
most powerful nation in the world, held a grudge. A Mesopotamian tyrant
had been defying the United States for more than a decade, although
thwarted in an attack on its neighbor by Bush's father. But Dad hadn't
quite finished the job, and word was that the tyrant had plotted to
assassinate him. It was even possible that he was behind a savage
terrorist attack on two major cities, and that he harbored weapons of
mass destruction. Now the time had come to settle scores. You should
attack Iraq and topple Saddam Hussein, Bush's neocon advisers urged. It
will enhance your reputation, and make people think twice before
attacking our territory.
King Xerxes, as it happens, feared he might not be the
leader his father was. So proving himself the equal of
Darius and previous Persian conquerers was always on his mind. "When I
became the king of Persia," he told the men he'd gathered to announce
his invasion plans, "I began to wonder how to avoid being left behind
by those who preceded me in this position of honor."
Texas Air National Guard dropout George W. Bush, son of a war hero
whose 1991 coalition crushed the Iraqi army in 100 hours, also worried
about being left behind, and thought he knew how to avoid it. "One of
the keys to being seen as a great leader," he told a journalist in
1999, "is to be seen as a commander-in-chief."
The neocons in
Xerxes' administration very much liked the idea of a Greek invasion.
"Who is going to oppose you?" asked Mardonius, Xerxes' Rumsfeld. "When
it comes to military matters there is no one in the world to match us."
But
Xerxes also had his Colin Powell -- his uncle, Artabanus, who counseled
a caution borne of painful experience. "I told your father, my brother
Darius, not to attack the Scythians ... but he didn't listen to me. So
he launched a campaign against them and when he came back he had lost a
great many brave fighting men."
(Scythia -- Persia's Vietnam.)
"Even
a massive army may be destroyed by a small force if it attracts the
god's resentment," Artabanus warned. "This happens because the god does
not allow anyone but himself to feel pride. The offspring of haste in
any venture is error, and error in turn tends to lead to serious harm."
But
warnings against haste and hubris did not deter Xerxes. He remained
firm in his desire to become a war king and, in 480, led his forces out
of present-day Turkey on its march for Greece.
When the Persians
reached the Hellespont, where Xerxes would have his men construct a
bridge for the crossing to Europe, Artabanus had one last shot at
getting the king to consider the risks of an invasion -- despite
Xerxes' admonition that "We shouldn't talk about bad things when
involved in good things like our current project."
"A man of true caliber," Artabanus said, "is one who combines fear when laying his plans,
so that he weighs up everything that might happen to him, with courage
in carrying them out."
To
which Xerxes replied, "Prizes are invariably won ... by those who are
prepared to act, rather than by those who weigh everything up and
hesitate." He then sent his uncle home.
And so Xerxes continued the quest for whatever "prize" he hoped to win.
All went
well; the Persians rampaged down the Greek peninsula and massacred King
Leonidas and 300 Spartans at Thermopylae, then marched on Athens,
where they burned down the Acropolis. The Athenians had abandoned their
city, and were huddled in fear on the tiny nearby island of Salamis --
where
their navy, outnumbered by roughly (accounts vary) three to one, routed
the Persian fleet, sending them in panic across the Aegean to the port
city of Mycale. The following year the Greeks wiped out Persia's land
forces at Plataea, north of Athens, and finished off the the remaining
Persian ships at Mycale.
Because the fledgling Athenian
democracy would have been extinguished had Persia prevailed -- along
with subsequent achievements in philosophy, science, and drama that
together form the foundation of Western civilization -- the Battle of
Salamis is often called the single most important military encounter in
history. So we should all be grateful for King Xerxes' many personal
failings: his hubris. His need to prove himself his father's equal. His
reckless haste in the attempt to assure his place in history. His unwillingness to
"weigh everything up" and imagine outcomes other than easy victory --
to "talk about bad things."
As Artabanus had warned that day at
the Hellespont 2,500 years ago, "Complex affairs inevitably require
further thought." And the world's mightiest nation paid a steep price
because of the lack of it.
The irony is, George W. Bush majored in history.
Steve Horowitz is a freelance political and advertising writer in Hollywood, Fla.
|
||||||||
|
If you love your country and hate what Bush is doing to it, this is the blog for you.
Visual aids
Links
Chronicicle of the Dark Ages
|
The ancient failings of George W. Bush
Comments
Re: The ancient failings of George W. Bush
Bravo!
Brilliant synthesis of history past and present. Damned shame that some people seem to be incapable of learning. Re: The ancient failings of George W. Bush
by
skippy
on Wed 20 Dec 2006 06:45 PM EST | Permanent Link
good blog, keep up the good work!
Re: Re: The ancient failings of George W. Bush
by
Anonymous
on Thu 29 Nov 2007 10:23 PM EST | Permanent Link
I'd like it if you all went to hell, please and thank you. For bashing the man who does everything he can for this country, for our troops. Despite the fact that he has a thousand pounds of pressure on his shoulders, the majority of the time, he makes the correct decisions. How ungrateful all of you are. I'm a little too angry right now to debate, so...Good riddens.
Re: Re: Re: The ancient failings of George W. Bush
by
stevecopy
on Fri 30 Nov 2007 04:35 PM EST | Profile | Permanent Link
Please and thank you very much for once again proving that people who support the moron in the Oval Office are morons themselves. What you and your fellow Bush supporters really want is someone who will tell you that you don't need to get involved -- "Trust me, I'll take care of everything. You just go on about your little lives, watching Dancing with the Stars while I strangle the world's preeminent democratic system." What you're really saying good "riddens" to is your rights.
Re: The ancient failings of George W. Bush
by
skippy
on Wed 20 Dec 2006 06:45 PM EST | Permanent Link
good blog, keep up the good work!
Re: The ancient failings of George W. Bush
by
Anonymous
on Thu 11 Jan 2007 08:07 PM EST | Permanent Link
Bush team wants 92,000 more bodies for Iraq?
Hmmm... That's: 115,000 gallons of blood 34 tons of heart 87,400 pounds of kidney 276,000 pounds of liver 276,000 pounds of brain 6,440,000 grams of tongue 4, 140,000 feet of large and small intestine, or 784 miles worth of guts (that's longer than the state of Florida by 200 miles) 184,000 eyeballs and 18,952,000 shiny white bones. Hmmm... -nativebuddha Re: The ancient failings of George W. Bush
by
Anonymous
on Thu 15 Nov 2007 01:18 PM EST | Permanent Link
Re: The ancient failings of George W. Bush
by
Anonymous
on Sun 13 Jan 2008 02:57 PM EST | Permanent Link
Ah yes...Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it-- George Santayana.
Might I also add..learn from it as well. I still believe that American democracy will be seen by future historians as an overtouted political science experiment. Re: The ancient failings of George W. Bush
by
2ndgen.bl.devil
on Wed 09 Apr 2008 12:35 PM EDT | Profile | Permanent Link
Most American leaders since 1945 have known up close and personal the horrors of war. George Dubya has no idea what war is all about the only thing he knows is that his kids and none of his friends kids will have to go; He didn't. We have seen what happens to the voice of dissention in the good ol' U.S. of A.. There was Phil Donahue who is anti war and expressed his views on national T.V.. Phil lost his job. The news anchor with years of experience who said that George Dubya was not a good National Guardsman, he lost his job. Anybody who expresses an anti Bush, anti-war, opinion on a national forum is silenced. Well the media in the U.S. was once unbiased and fair, now it reminds me of the media in {well what I've read about it } during the 60'sw, 70's, and 80's in Russia.
If you thought Clinton should have been impeached, {as I did, not for having sex in the oval office (I'm sure many presidents have had sex in the oval office) but for lying to congress.} If you think "Tricky Dicky" should have been impeached. Well I for one do not know how Georgey Dubya made it through the first tem without being impeached. |
Login
NewsWire
Reality Check
Keeping up with what God hates
Naked conservatives
Search
Recent Articles
Recent Comments
Recent Visitors
Patrick - Tue 13 May 2008 06:35 PM EDT
2ndgen.bl.devil - Wed 09 Apr 2008 08:27 PM EDT
BlueState - Thu 17 Jan 2008 03:37 PM EST
artemis133 - Wed 09 Jan 2008 09:02 PM EST
stevecopy - Wed 09 Jan 2008 12:46 PM EST
This Month
Month Archive
Recent Trackbacks
|
||||||
|
||||||||


